RSS

Tag Archives: sherlock holmes

Review of The Lost Stories of Sherlock Holmes from Tony Reynolds, by An Ill-dressed Vagabond

Philip K Jones (aka The Ill Dressed Vagabond ) is one of the leading Holmes reviewers in the USA. Here is his recent review of ‘The Lost Stories of Sherlock Holmes’ by Tony Reynolds.

This is the first Sherlockian writing I have found by this author. It is a collection of eight short novellas, each set up similarly to the Canonical tales. Other than the language, which seems a bit modern, these tales read a lot like their originals.

`The Giant Rat of Sumatra” takes place in London and migrates from a tale of murder to a story of a curiosity and then to a true tragedy. The explanation offered is plausible and the events are reasonable. “The Adventure of the Gypsy Girl” reads very well. Holmes always seems a step ahead of the reader and gives his client what she asks for. It is quite well executed and seems to unfold naturally.

“The Adventure of the Amazon Explorer” recalls a couple of the Canonical tales and includes several excellent deductions by Holmes. Again, Holmes satisfies his client’s needs, if not those of the Metropolitan Police. “The Adventure of the Medium” starts out as if it is another fraud debunking as in the earlier “Gypsy Girl” tale. It ends up as a tale of Holmes’ compassion and understanding.

“The Adventure of the Russian Anarchist” has Holmes requested by a high Government Official to help prevent the assassination of a visiting diplomat. Holmes manages to do so, despite the advice and help provided by his client and by Inspector Lestrade. “The Adventure of the Eminent Collector” involves Holmes in an inexplicable robbery. The stolen object and the pains taken simply do not match, so Holmes finds the explanation.

“The Adventure of the Pawnbroker’s Wife leads Holmes and Watson into an increasingly dark and involved situation. Their client’s suspicions seem to be confirmed and then magnified as the case progresses. “The Mystery of the Missing Rubies” introduces us to a family of Holmes relatives. Sherlock and Watson travel to Yorkshire to spend the Christmas holidays with some Holmes cousins and Mycroft joins the party. This is not a Mycroft I recognize, but the crime is explained so a good holiday can be had by all.

The individual stories are all reasonably framed and well-written. I found only a handful of errors and disliked only the characterization of Mycroft in the final tale. All were enjoyable, moderately complex and believable. Perhaps they are not Canonical, but they make a very nice substitute.

The Lost Stories of Sherlock Holmes are available from all good bookstores worldwide, on Amazon, Amazon Kindle, Kobo Books and iBooks (iPad/iPhone).

 

Tags: , ,

Review of ‘In Search of Dr Watson’ from Molly Carr by An Ill-dressed Vagabond

An Ill-dressed Vagabond is one of the most respected Sherlock Holmes reviewers in the USA. Here is his review of Molly Carr’s fascinating biography of Dr.Watson from May 2011.

“This book is a study of the sources and uses of John H. Watson as presented in the sixty Sherlockian tales written by Sir Arthur Conan Doyle.

The author examines the relationship between the characters of Holmes and Watson in a careful fashion to determine why Doyle chose to create Watson as both a foil and a counterpoint for Holmes and how that choice affected the style and development of the stories over the forty years in which they were written. In addition, similar characters in Literature are discussed and analyzed to provide examples of alternative methods and the problems involved in using such figures.

While this seems to be a simple task, it is really anything but simple. The unique nature of Sherlock Holmes as an Archetype of Literature, ‘The Great Detective,’ is actually dependent on the methods Doyle used to present him. These methods all come down to using Watson as narrator, question asker, foil and stalking horse. The two personas of Holmes and Watson together allow the author to select the data to be presented to the readers in a very careful fashion. Holmes can maintain his own counsel without revealing answers before the author is ready. In addition, space and time can be devoted to various items of byplay between the two that constitute ‘filler’ for the stories that would otherwise be rather dry and dull.

In addition to a discussion of the methods Doyle used in writing and the uses he made of Watson, the author needs to discuss the many controversial features of the Sherlockian tales. These include time and dating problems, names of both persons and places, and identification of real events and persons, either included in or excluded from the tales. Most of these discussion items are familiar to Sherlockians, but are presented here in a comprehensive fashion with analyses of several different approaches and aspects. Total agreement is not really possible, but the author works to untangle the mare’s nest and to explain many of the sources of the problems.

Finally, the inspiration for names and places mentioned is examined and several ideas are offered that may help readers to understand what might have been in Doyle’s mind at various times. Several surprising triggers are identified and others proposed as real world inspirations for places, persons and events that showed up in the tales.

This is an interesting and well-written summary of the data available about John H. Watson. It covers a lot of territory and does so in a readable and interesting fashion. Experienced Sherlockians will recognize many points of discussion and readers new to ‘The Grand Game’ will find a strong introduction to Sherlockian ‘higher criticism.’”

In Search of Dr Watson is available from all good bookstores and in all formats worldwide including Amazon, Barnes and Noble, Amazon Kindle, Kobo Books and iBooks (iPad/iPhone).

 

Tags: , , , , ,

A World Without Sherlock Holmes? – That Would Be The Reality Without Bertram Fletcher Robinson

In 2011 we finally have the irrefutable evidence behind the success of the Sherlock Holmes character and it was unveiled by Devon author and Holmes investigator, Paul R Spiring. In a local newspaper articles from the Herald Express and Western Morning News and in a BBC Wales radio interview Paul revealed how he came across the letters that prove that Arthur Conan Doyle had more than a little help with the key story that launched Holmes worldwide.

Winding the clock back to the early 20th century and Arthur Conan Doyle had killed Holmes off and while the character had achieved some limited success, this was largely restricted to the UK. A lifelong friend of Conan Doyle’s was a young man, himself an accomplished writer, called Bertram Fletcher Robinson. Not much was known about Robinson, other than that he had died tragically young, before the acclaimed biography published in 2008 called simply ‘Betram Fletcher Robinson – A Footnote To The Hound Of The Baskervilles‘ written and compiled by Spiring and Brian W Pugh.

In the biography Spiring and Pugh talk about the great friendship between Robinson and Conan Doyle and how they had ‘collaborated’ on ‘The H0und’ and that Robinson was often referred to as the ‘assistant plot producer’ for the book. The biography talks about a very talented writer who also collaborated with such big names as PG Wodehouse – you can read their main works in the 2009 book ‘Bobbles and Plum‘, and Max Pemberton on ‘Wheels of Anarchy‘ , but it was his friendship with Conan Doyle that is of the greatest interest.

Without a doubt if it wasn’t for ‘The Hound‘ there would be no Sherlock Holmes today. No movies, no BBC TV series, no legions of fans around the world. It was the story that turned Holmes into the worldwide phenomenon that has led to millions of fans, many films, hundreds of books and and ongoing legacy for Conan Doyle.

So what has Spiring uncovered? Quite simply the written proof that Conan Doyle paid his friend the modern day equivalent of £45,000 [£500 at the time] for his help on the story. Conan Doyle was due to receive an estimated £1/2m in modern day values for the story so the payment to Robinson was about 10% of what Conan Doyle was to get. This proves, beyond reasonable doubt, that Robinson made a significant contribution to the storyline. It is well documented that Conan Doyle lent on friends and particularly family for ideas and indeed characters for his storylines but for him to go as far as handing over such a huge sum of money for the input is significant.

What a shame it is that Robinson was taken from us at such a young age, dying shortly after from poisoning [in his biography Spring and Pugh go into the accusations that Conan Doyle was the one that poisoned him]. He was a very talented writer of similar storylines to Conan Doyle as well as the playlets he wrote with Wodehouse. You can read twenty of his stories in ‘Aside Arthur Conan Doyle‘ which was also compiled by Spiring.

So in summary, all Holmes fans need to give a big thanks to Bertram Fletcher Robinson, without whom they would not have their wonderful character – and personally a big thankyou to Paul Spiring for proving it once and for all.

ACD, Sherlock Holmes and Devon

ACD, Sherlock Holmes and Devon

Bertram Fletcher Robinson

Aside ACD

 

Tags: , , ,

Book Review – The Official Papers into the Matter Known as ‘The Hound of the Baskervilles’ – Sherlock Holmes Society of London

As a retired detective with the Metropolitan Police Keiron Freeburn has excellent experience which he has used to great effect with a very unusual take on The Hound of The Baskervilles. As with several reviews of this fascinating book the societies have been tough on the small mistakes, but another resounding thumbs up for a very unusual and memorable Holmes pastiche.

“What we have here, apparently, are facsimiles of the original case files from both Scotland Yard and Devon County Constabulary. In fact this collection of witness statements, medical reports, and police reports is the work of a former member of the Metropolitan Police CID, now living in Devon. The project is very nicely done, providing a fresh and completely valid view of the investigation. In particular it’s good to know how the two police forces regarded the summoning of a Scotland Yard man without reference to the Devon Constabulary!

There are some careless errors (the post-mortem report on Sir Charles Baskerville has Sir Henry’s name on the first page; Mrs Lyons is called “Miss Lyons” throughout; Selden’s name changes from Arthur to Albert; Barrymore once refers to his wife as his sister). Such matters are easily attended to, though. A corrected edition of this fascinating and very worthwhile new look at a familiar classic will be something to treasure.”

The book is available from all good bookstores around the world – as the whole point of the book is the Victorian fonts the book is only available in printed format [so no Kindle or iPad versions].

In the USA the book is available from Amazon and Barnes and Noble.

In the UK the book is available from Amazon, Book Depository [free worldwide delivery], and Waterstones.

Official Papers into the matter of The Hound of The Baskervilles

Official Papers into the matter of The Hound of The Baskervilles

 
Leave a comment

Posted by on January 3, 2011 in Book Reviews

 

Tags: , , , ,

Book Review – The Sign of Fear – Sherlock Holmes Society of London

‘The Sign of Fear’ is the first in a series of Holmes pastiche novels from Molly Carr, a life long Dr. Watson expert. It features Mrs. Watson as a strong female lead character andthe book has gained very posititive reviews from Holme societies around the world. Here, Roger Johnson from the Sherlock Holmes Society of London reviews the book for their newsletter;

 

“Never mind what you’ve been told: the former Mary Morstan is a woman with a past — so perhaps it’s natural that she should come within the orbit of the Napoleon of Crime. At least we can understand that she should occupy the time during Dr Watson’s long absences by doing detective work herself. More surprising is the identity of her partner, a dangerous young woman to whom male costume is nothing new: “Emily Fanshaw” is actually Mrs Neville St Clair, and she still resents the fact that Sherlock Holmes cut short her husband’s profitable scam by exposing him as the beggar with the twisted lip…

There are more surprises in Mary Watson’s memoirs, not least the revelation that John H Watson, who never qualified as a doctor, was born Ormond Sacker and changed his name by deed poll! Other dubious characters encountered by the intrepid duo include A J Raffles, Bunny Manders, John Clay, Mrs Marple (mother of Jane), and M. Poirot (father of Hercule). Rather like M J Trow’s stories of Inspector Lestrade, the book takes a distinctly revisionist approach to the Canon. The Sign of Fear is something of a guilty pleasure, perhaps, but a pleasure it certainly is!”

Roger Johnson, Sherlock Holmes Society of London

 

The Sign of Fear is available from all good bookstores including Amazon USA, Barnes and Noble USAAmazon UK, Amazon Kindle USA, Book Depository (free delivery to Canada and India), and for the iPad and iPhone through iTunes iBooks.

The sequel to The Sign of Fear, ‘A Study In Crimson‘ was release in November 2010.

 

 
Leave a comment

Posted by on December 31, 2010 in Book Reviews

 

Tags: , , ,

Arthur Conan Doyle, Sherlock Holmes and Devon, A Complete Tour Guide – A New Book of Key Sites that Inspired Sherlock Holmes

Arthur Conan Doyle, Sherlock Holmes and Devon

Arthur Conan Doyle, Sherlock Holmes and Devon

The time that Arthur Conan Doyle spent in Devon was critical. It was only when he wrote ‘The Hound of The Baskervilles’ did Sherlock Holmes become a worldwide phenomenon. It was there, on Dartmoor that Conan Doyle got the inspiration for what was to become the most famous, and most important, crime fiction mystery of all time. Two leading Holmes historians Paul R. Spiring and Brian W. Pugh have teamed up with a Devonian historian Sandru Bhanji to create the definitive guide to Sherlock Holmes and Devon. Arthur Conan Doyle, Sherlock Holmes and Devon: A Complete Tour Guide & Companion (MX Publishing,15th June) contains detailed descriptions, background and even GPS co-ordinates for thirty key Sherlock Holmes and Arthur Conan Doyle sites across Devon.

Key towns featured include Plymouth, Yelverton, Buckfastleigh, Ashburton, Newton Abbot, Ippleton, Paignton, Torquay, Exeter, and Lynton.

The Hound Of The Baskervilles - Image from the Strand Magazine

In November 1887, Beeton’s Christmas Annual published a story entitled A Study in Scarlet that was written by a twenty-eight year old Southsea-based physician called Arthur Conan Doyle. It was the first of sixty stories that he wrote over forty years that each feature the now iconic literary detective, Mr Sherlock Holmes. This character has since appeared in around two-hundred and thirty films making him probably the most filmed fictional character of all time.

The definitive tour guide for anyone looking to retrace the steps, physically or virtually, of Arthur Conan Doyle during his time in Devon and see the places that inspired the Sherlock Holmes stories.

The long-lasting appeal of Sherlock Holmes is due first and foremost to the story writing skills of Arthur Conan Doyle. However, there is little doubt that had it not been for three residents of Devon, the history of crime fiction might have been very different indeed. Firstly, George Turnavine Budd engineered the circumstances that prompted Conan Doyle to relocate to Southsea and spend more time at his writing-desk. Secondly, George Newnes delivered the Sherlock Holmes tales to a broad readership via the pages of the British and American editions of The Strand Magazine. Thirdly, Bertram Fletcher Robinson was pivotal to the inception of The Hound of the Baskervilles, which first appeared some eight years after Conan Doyle had ‘slain’ Holmes ‘for good and all’ in only his twenty-sixth adventure.

In fact, Arthur Conan Doyle wrote in a British edition of The Hound –

“MY DEAR ROBINSON, It was to your account of a West-Country legend that this tale owes its inception. For this and for your help in the details all thanks. Yours most truly,
A. CONAN DOYLE, HINDHEAD, HASLEMERE.”

Bill Barnes, Chairman of the Sherlock Holmes group The Sydney Passengers comments:

“If George Newnes had not founded the immensely popular Strand Magazine at the time that Conan Doyle wrote his first two Sherlock Holmes short stories and then commissioned many more after their success then perhaps the Holmes adventures would have taken a lot longer to reach such a wide readership, if at all.

If Bertram Fletcher Robinson and Conan Doyle had not become such firm friends on the ship home from South Africa and thereafter Fletcher Robinson had fired up Conan Doyle’s imagination with legendary tales of huge phantom dogs and the wilds of Dartmoor then maybe The Hound of the Baskervilles might not have been written, or have been written very differently.

Sir George Newnes c1905

This book contains a wealth of information – hard facts and interesting trivia – and displays considerable research and talent upon the part of the authors to present it so as to appeal to people across a broad spectrum. Anybody with the slightest interest in the history of Devon, the writings of Arthur Conan Doyle, the Sherlock Holmes phenomenon or the early days of popular publishing in Victorian and Edwardian times (the ‘New Journalism’) will find this book a highly interesting read and an indispensable reference. The expansive and comprehensive touring notes will take you to many interesting points and having this book in the car or backpack as you explore Devon will be like having the three authors along with you as knowledgeable tour guides.”

Arthur Conan Doyle, Sherlock Holmes and Devon: A Complete Tour Guide and Companion is released on 15th June 2010 and will be a fun read for both the traditional Sherlock Holmes enthusiast and the new breed fuelled by the recent Guy Richie reincarnation in the Hollywood movie Sherlock Holmes starring Jude Law and Robert Downey Junior. Guy Ritchie’s Sherlock Holmes has won many awards already including the best action film at the 2010 National Movie Awards , a Golden Globe, IFTA and Empire awards. Through the book fans can see the original places that inspired in particular the ground breaking ‘The Hound Of The Baskervilles’.

About The Authors
Brian W. Pugh is the Curator of The Arthur Conan Doyle (Crowborough) Establishment where he maintains the modest collection of Arthur Conan Doyle ephemera that is held by that organisation and their official website The Conan Doyle Crowborough Establishment. He is the sole author of A Chronology of the Life of Sir Arthur Conan Doyle and also the joint author of On the Trail of Arthur Conan Doyle and Bertram Fletcher Robinson. Brian is a member of numerous Holmesian groups including The Sherlock Holmes Society of London. He lives at Lewes and is a retired former British Gas Engineering Supervisor.

Paul R. Spiring is a Chartered Biologist and Physicist. He is currently seconded by the British Government to work as the Head of Biology at the European School of Karlsruhe in Germany. Paul is also the joint author of On the Trail of Arthur Conan Doyle and Bertram Fletcher Robinson and has compiled a further four related books. He also maintains a tribute website that commemorates the memory of Bertram Fletcher Robinson BFR Onilne and is a member of the Devonshire Association and a number of Holmesian groups.

Sadru Bhanji is Vice-Chairman of the Devon and Exeter Institution and also Treasurer of the Exeter Branch of the Devonshire Association and past Treasurer of the Devon History Society. He is the author of Barbary Pirates Off the Devon Coast and Postcards from Topsham. Sadru has produced over thirty papers on Devon’s local history for various journals including The Lancet, Transactions of the Devonshire Association, The Devon Historian and Devon and Cornwall Notes and Queries. He lives at Topsham near Exeter and is a retired Consultant Psychiatrist and University Lecturer.

 

Tags: , , , , , , , , , , ,

Lady Mystery Writer Brings a Female Sherlock Holmes To Life

Hats off to Molly Carr whose debut novel ‘The Sign Of Fear‘ is a wonderful book that charts the adventures of Mrs.Watson, the wife of Dr.Watson and her sidekick Emily Fanshaw. With a supporting cast of Sherlock Holmes, Dr.Watson and Moriarty it is a great story and a fresh female approach to the Holmes canon.

The number of female crime writers is rising with the increasing popularity of Tess Gerritsen, Elizabeth George, Karen Rose, Lynda La Plante, Janet Enavnovich, and Kathy Reichs among others. However, one genre within mystery fiction has remained largely male dominated – that of Sherlock Holmes.

One look at the top 100 books for Sherlock Holmes will have you struggling to find any female authors, let alone the share that mainstream crime fiction now has – and that’s a real shame. As soon as you get into ‘The Sign Of Fear’ you can see and feel the female perspective and it’s fascinating to experience Victorian England from a woman’s point of view.

Molly’s main character is Mrs.Watson and the old phrase ‘behind every great man there is a great woman’ is very true here as she cuts straight to the chase as a formidable leading lady in her own right.

A great detective needs a sidekick and Mrs.Watson is no exception. Emily Fanshaw does however spend a good part of the book disguised as a man – a necessity born out of the time. Some of the most intersting and amusing action takes place in France giving Molly a chance to throw out some lovely sterotypes from her English characters.

The Sign Of Fear

The story is told through the first person of Mrs.Watson is a delightful Victorian manner and use of language is excellent and refreshingly traditional – the use of words like ‘retort’ and ‘exude’ bring a smile to your face . There is much of the ‘Jeeves and Wooster’ style here and I am sure Molly won’t mind being compared to PG Wodehouse.

The Sign of Fear is relased across the world on 15th June 2010 and will be a fun read for both the traditional Sherlock Holmes enthusiast and the new breed fuelled by the recent Guy Richie reincarnation.

 

Tags: , , , , ,

Visiting London And Looking For A Different Kind Of Travel Guide?

So you are on your way to London and you want to visit some of the best places, but don’t want to be the average kind of tourist? Several visitors from the USA in particular are turning the clock back 100 years and following in the footsteps of the world’s most famous detective – Sherlock Holmes. Holmes historian Alistair Duncan came up with the brilliant idea of basing a guide around the places that appear in Holmes stories, but that were also dear to the author Sir Arthur Conan Doyle.

‘Close To Holmes’ takes us around the main locations and includes some of my particular favourites as well. The British Museum was featured in several stories and was a particular favourite of Conan Doyle’s. Alistair combines a light and friendly commentary with pictures from the late 1800s and the modern day.

Regent Street c1880

Regent Street c1880

“Reading it, we feel that we’re in the company of a knowledgeable, enthusiastic and witty friend. The book is both valuable and a pleasure to read. As much a historical and literary exploration as a travel guide” The Sherlock Holmes Society of London

There are several of London’s oldest hotels in the book including the Savoy and The Langham along with very famous streets such as Pall Mall, Charing Cross Road, The Strand and of course the home of Sherlock Holmes himself Baker Street.

Also worth a visit are Covent Garden and Scotland Yard that have their own chapters in the book.

There is a growing Facebook group of those that have used the book as a guide with their own comments and pictures – Close To Holmes Photo Stories.

For those lucky people with an Amazon Kindle the book has been recently launched on Kindle and its the perfect way to take the guide with you – Close To Holmes on Kindle.

Close To Holmes

Close To Holmes

 

Tags: , , , ,

Facebook Community Marketing – Sherlock Holmes Groups

Alistair Duncan’s last book Close To Holmes is a companion for those Sherlock Holmes fans that visit London and want to retrace the steps of Sir Arthur Conan Doyle (ACD) and visit the places that featured in the Holmes stories and those that were dear to the author.

This sets the scene for what Facebook does best – bring together people with very specific interests to share information and images about their chosen subject. In this case it is Sherlock Holmes fans that have used Alistair’s book on a visit to London – Close to Holmes Photo Stories.

There are hundreds of thousands of groups on Facebook and those that seem to be enduring are those that have a reason for lots of additional content on a regular basis – keeping the group members coming back again and again . Alistair’s is an excellent example of that – the key element of the group is the photos from the Holmes fans as they visit the various locations around London – including The British Museum, Covent Garden, Norwood, Croydon and dozens more.

In June this year another book Arthur Conan Doyle, Sherlock Holmes and Devon: A Complete Tour Guide & Companion will cover ACD’s time in Devon and showing the changing times will include all the GPS locations for all of the sites so that the intrepid fans armed with their iPhones (and no doubt iPads by then) and other GPS enabled devices will be able to effortlessly travel around without the need to print maps.

No doubt author Paul R Spiring will create a similar group on Facebook. Both authors have excellent blogs to support their online activities – in fact, Paul’s BFROnline is one of the most visited Holmes and ACD blogs in the world despite being originally set up to chart ACD’s close friend Bertram Fletcher Robinson‘s (BFR) short but stunning life.

Close To Holmes

Close To Holmes

So the new world for authors, where they themselves are becoming brands also means learning a whole new series of marketing tools that didn’t exist a few years ago. So set up your Facebook group and drive traffic to it from your Blog and Tweets and reflect back to the day when marketing as a publisher meant faxes and promo sheets in the post to the dozens of bookstore chains (RIP Borders, only Waterstones and the independents left now).

 

Tags: , , , , ,

New Arthur Conan Doyle Book Gets Rave Review

Alistair Duncan’s new book ‘The Norwood Author – Arthur Conan Doyle and the Norwood Years (1891 – 1894)’ has received its first major review – 4 stars and a glowing report from The Bookbag.

The book covers a critical stage in Conan Doyle’s life – and one that has been rarely covered by other historians.

“This book does an excellent job in detailing his activities as a resident of Norwood. There is a comprehensive choice of illustrations, both old and new, and appendices on relevant articles about him in the ‘Norwood News’ as well as his cricket performances. Also included is a brief note of what happened to him and his contemporaries in the ensuing years, and on how Norwood celebrates the legacy of their famous resident over a hundred years later, not least with an exhibition at the local Wetherspoons. The solid research has clearly been a labour of love, and the result is a concise volume with which no Conan Doyle enthusiast should be with out.”

The book comes out on the 1st March and is one of the most eagerly awaited by Doyleans.

The full review is available at  The Bookbag

The Norwood Author

The Norwood Author

 

Tags: , , , , ,